Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Deadenders and more

Quick, who reads comics and graphic novels? Teens, kids, and "weirdos," right? That's the stereotype anyway. The truth is much more varied than that, however. Men and women of all ages read comics, and for many different reasons. The readings from Weiner this week go into more detail about who reads comics and why. While these articles were interesting, I didn't learn much new information, aside from the more academic classification system used to describe these reasons.


However, Boyer's discussion about getting graphic novels into the hands of patrons who might not be normally inclined to consider the format struck a cord with me. Just last week at Barnes and Noble, a customer came up to me and asked for books about  Holocaust survivors. Of course, my immediate thought was Maus, which I showed her and recommended heartily. She seemed to think graphic novel could only be fiction, and she wanted nonfiction, so I tried to explain how Speigelman uses visual metaphor to portray the horrific events that his father lived through. She seemed reassured, but still hesitant, so I also showed her the handful of other Holocaust memoirs we had and told her to try reading a few pages of each. Later, she came by to thank me and showed me she had purchased Maus volume 1 and a book of short essays from Holocaust survivors. Success! Maybe she will like the format and maybe she won't, but at least now she knows the format can be used for nonfiction, and knows she has a greater choice in what materials are available to her.


Let's talk about Deadenders. I'm about halfway through it and so far I have mixed feelings about it. 
http://d1466nnw0ex81e.cloudfront.net/n_iv/600/1172177.jpg

First what I liked in mini comic form:
I tried anyway. Now some bullet points to finish off the likes.
  • The overall story. I'm a sucker for futuristic dystopias with a mysterious premise. Why is there no weather? What was the cataclysm? Why can Beezer see these visions? I want to know!
  • The complex relationships between the characters. Beezer is dating Sophie, who is flirted with by Hal who doesn't like Beezer, but still helps him out. Sophie then leaves Beezer for Daniel who may have loved her at another time but doesn't remember. Jasper is Beezer's best friend who is daing Danica, until he dies, at which point she and Beezer start hooking up regularly. The drama.
  • The way the story changed perspective. This kept it feeling fresh and just happens to be one of my favorite writing styles.

Now, what I had problems with: 
  • Beezer is so angsty/angry all the time, with basically everyone around him. WHAT ARE WE YELLING ABOUT? He very much reminded me of Harry Potter circa book 5. So many bottled up emotions that could just not be contained, except when anyone asked him to talk about it, in which case he clammed right up.
  • The stereotypes of boys going out and doing all the crazy, dangerous, exciting stuff, while the girls hung out and waited passively for things to happen and then nursing their guys back to health.
  • The constant ever present drug use. Personal opinion, just not my thing.
  • What's up with the weird Archie callback?
I'm looking forward to finishing it anyway!


4 comments:

  1. Anna seemed to break away from the passive tendencies of the other female characters, but I also felt that she wasn't a very well-developed character. At the end of the story, I still didn't have a very clear idea who she was. This seemed like a significant shortcoming given her role in the story's resolution and the fact that she ends up with Beezer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I just finished Deadenders this evening, and I agree, we never really find out much about Anna's inner life. I also didn't like the resolution, mainly because I didn't really understand what happened, this time travel premise was set up, but I'm not sure what they did differently this time that actually fixed everything. Oh well.

      Delete
  2. Loved the Harry Potter Book 5 reference, and the mini comic you made! How did you do that?

    Kudos on introducing graphic novels to an untapped audience member :)


    ps. aly wrote this for some reason when i approve it, it says anonymous

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I made the mini comic using photoshop. Found a comics layout template, threw some gradient backgrounds in, found a relevant scene from Deadenders, used a LOT of filters and freehand on a photo of me, and then added titles. It ended up being a mini comic cause I spent way too much time on the one page and didn't have time to do more, glad you liked it though :)

      Delete